Sarah’s Peanut Butter Cups


Are you a peanut butter and chocolate lover? Our milk or dark chocolate cups will fulfill your desires and delight your taste buds. They are truly amazing – our mouths water just talking about them. We use an all natural peanut butter that we blend with our chocolate and then overfill our fresh made chocolate cups. The result is a perfect balance of chocolate and peanut butter. We introduce to you our newest creation – the Colossal peanut butter cup! Made with the same recipe as our regular sized peanut butter cups – these will surely bring giant smiles! Regular sized are packaged in decorative/seasonal bags, colossal are packaged as singles in clear cello bags.

You may never be satisfied with other peanut butter cups again – sorry! There are no artificial flavors, no fillers – just peanut butter and chocolate. It’s your taste buds dream come true!

Gluten Free.

Store Hours

M-F: 9am - 5:30pm
Saturday: 9am- 5pm
Sunday: closed